Monday, January 26, 2015

Overthrow ad cubes השמידו את קוביות החוצות



While many have observed that the boundary in Israel between public and private space is far thinner than in the rest of the West – in some cases non-existent – I believe that I may be the first to point out its manifestation in the form of – wait for it – street signage. To illustrate, let’s first look at this unencumbered street sign in Brisbane:

Couldn’t be clearer where you are, right? Now before we look at some street signs in Israel’s two major cities, recall that street signs are 1) a tax-funded utility aimed at the citizens’ welfare and 2) meant to convey important navigational information to locals and visitors (hey Tourism Ministry, that means you) alike. With those two purposes in mind, let’s see how we’re doing:



Recall that motor travel through cities takes place at speeds of 50-90 kph. A driver or navigator at those speeds is therefore not just not served by these travesties of street signs, but may actually be in danger of causing a collision while trying to figure out where the h_ll s/he is. Not to mention that many of our street signs are broken and / or illegible
, or simply incorrect:

But apparently the cities of Tel Aviv and Jerusalem so badly need the revenue from the ad cubes that block or obstruct street "signs" that they sell ad space at the expense of the citizenry. In other words, that’s your municipal taxes funding broken, incorrect, and obstructed street "signs"!

Moreover, if it were such a crucial revenue stream for the cities, how come multiple image searches for “street-level advertising” found not a single instance in any other city in the world? You’re telling me this revenue stream is efficacious in only two world cities?

And by the way, the atrocious ad cubes are not part of some neoliberal plot to divert all the middle class’s hard-earned money to the tycoons: The ad cubes have been there as long as I can remember (1976), if not decades before. So what’s the deal? Why are we taking this sitting down? Has it not occurred to a single other Israeli that the cubes ride roughshod over our rights?

If so, why aren’t the citizens pressuring the cities to remove them? Why aren’t tour guides and others in the tourism industry pressuring the Visitors’ Bureaus, Chambers of Commerce, and the Tourism Ministry to get rid of them? Where are Rotary and other civic groups?

I propose a solution that serves everyone: Leave the cubes in place and convert them into street signs! They’re ideally situated and highly visible, thereby expediting the flow of traffic and everyone’s travels. Each side of the cube could be divided into two vertically: The top half would tell you what street you’re now on; the bottom half would indicate the cross street, thusly:
שנקין

Shenkin
_________________________________________________________________________


(יונתן) הסנדלר
[العربية]                                                 
(Yonatán) haSandlár
OK, so you see that I’m neither a semiologist nor a graphic artist (tried multiple times to get the triangle arrows situated alongside the text), but you get the idea. Just lose the word רח' [“street”]. It’s superfluous: We all know we’re on a street. It’s simple, clear, and conveys much more, and much more useful information than do the present “signs”.

Cities still want ad revenue? Mount solar-powered, slowly rotating cubes atop bus shelters, each side bearing a different ad. There: quadruple bang for your buck, no one’s vision is obstructed, win win. I hereby appeal to everyone reading this, especially if you’re a Tel Avivian, Jerusalemite, or work in tourism, to get the ball rolling. Time to take back the street signs!

6 comments:

  1. Yam, I find your post highly interesting. The case of street signs perfectly demonstrates the expansion of private interests at the expense of public ones in all aspects of life.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Mollie Saferstein NewmanJanuary 26, 2015 at 4:49 PM

    Minimalism isn't just a form of art. Street signs need to be clear and unfettered and LEGIBLE. You're so right about the word "Street" being superfluous -- I never thought of that! Excellent (bordering on brilliant) idea about the solar-powered rotating ads mounted on bus shelters. Yam, ya did it again. Now all you have to do is find someone smart in the city government who will give you five minutes to hear you out. = Mollie

    ReplyDelete
  3. Mollie Saferstein NewmanJanuary 26, 2015 at 4:55 PM

    Minimalism isn't just an art form; street signs need to be clear, clean, and legible. And you're right . . . there's no reason to put the word "street" after the name of the street! Your idea about mounting solar-powered revolving ads on bus shelters is excellent, bordering on brilliant. Now all you have to do is find someone smart in the city government who will give you five minutes to present your case. Persevere! Your idea is too good to lie dormant.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Mollie. Hoping the urbanites and those who work in tourism'll take my idea and run with it.

      Delete
  4. Marla Shalinsky Stein, licensed tour guideJanuary 27, 2015 at 11:32 AM

    I had NEVER even noticed these cubes,and now I'm obsessed with them!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Don't just obsess...act! The nice thing about this issue is that the Orthodox would likely get behind it: They and their businesses get deliveries just like everyone else, and they eschew advertising, so...win win.

      Delete